Here are the key differences between transformational and transactional leadership.
Table Of Contents
Transformational Leadership is when leaders actively engage with their subordinates to promote top-notch performance, encourage creativity, and seek input. They inspire, influence, and stimulate people intellectually and motivate them to take big-picture action, going beyond their immediate self-interests. They drive success through a transformational organizational environment for the organization's future.
Transformational leadership differs from the traditional work culture and management style, where subordinates defer to leaders for every decision, action, and requirement, even those within their capacities. The transformational leadership style allows businesses to adapt to changing situations and meet the organization's needs accordingly. It helps leaders and businesses survive in the market through deliberate transformations that prompt employees to perform better and contribute to organizational success.
Key Takeaways
Transformational leadership refers to leaders guiding people past immediate self-interests. They do this by influencing, inspiring, or intellectually stimulating people to perform well at work. This leadership style is characterized by visionary leaders who can instill a sense of purpose and a shared vision in their teams or organizations. They have excellent communication skills and develop an environment that fosters innovation, continuous improvement, and motivation to work toward a shared goal.
Transformational leaders do not micromanage and encourage a culture of autonomy and ownership among people. Employees are given space to transform the organization into one that is forward-thinking and constantly evolving or growing. The goal of such leaders is to inspire followers by setting an example for others using their creativity and other professional attributes.
Helping an organization grow beyond its current position, performance, and capabilities is a key component of transformational leadership. To achieve this, a leader must ensure creative problem-solving, have the capacity to handle complicated issues, and make tough decisions that need courage and confidence. These factors inspire people working under them to work harder and better. Transformational leadership can positively impact both businesses and individual employees when successfully implemented.
This happens due to high employee engagement and satisfaction, and employees are motivated to exceed performance expectations. A key attribute such leaders must have to deliver the required outcomes is the ability to reflect and manage their emotions in challenging situations. This has been discussed in greater detail in the section that follows.
Some key components or elements of the transformational leadership style are shown below.
Let us look at a few examples to understand the concept.
Dan is the owner of a software company. As a leader, Dan can follow the transformational leadership model to drive positive change and inspire his team. For this, Dan outlines a compelling and clear vision for the company's future, shares it with his staff, and emphasizes the advantages for clients and society. He organizes brainstorming meetings and innovation workshops to help his staff develop fresh ideas. He also challenges them to think critically and creatively. Through this, he questions accepted theories in software development.
Dan also cares about the development of his team members. He holds regular one-on-one meetings and offers mentorship. He also ensures adequate resources are available to help people realize their true potential. Thus, Dan leads by example, displaying passion, recognizing accomplishments, and inspiring a sense of commitment and purpose.
Deep Lead is a program developed in Finland for learning and coaching management. Based on scientific research about teaching and learning, it helps management teams, managers, sales teams, customer service representatives, and other experts achieve success at work. The program provides participants, organizations, and other communities with tools and models that help them change organizational culture. The results are measured based on four factors. They are Enthusiasm, Learning, Appreciation, and Trust. The leaders are expected to:
It is a transformational leadership model designed to help people grow.
Some common advantages and disadvantages of transformational leadership are:
Here are the key differences between transformational and transactional leadership.
Key Points | Transformational Leadership | Transactional Leadership |
---|---|---|
1. Concept | It affects individual behavior and social systems by transforming organizational methods. | It affects individual behavior and social systems by transforming organizational methods. |
2. Aim | The purpose of this leadership in its optimal state is to transform followers into leaders by bringing about significant positive change in them. | The purpose of this leadership in its optimal state is to transform followers into leaders by bringing about significant positive change in them. |
3. Motivation | This leadership style motivates employees through the inspiring actions of leaders. | This leadership style motivates employees through the inspiring actions of leaders. |
Here are the key differences between transformational, charismatic, and servant leadership styles.
Key Points | Transformational Leadership | Charismatic Leadership | Servant Leadership |
---|---|---|---|
Concept | Transformational leadership is an approach that focuses on altering the status quo and promoting employee engagement through motivated action. | Charismatic leadership is a system built on the leader's communication skills, charm, and persuasion skills. | It is a management approach that prioritizes the development and well-being of the team to meet their requirements. Such leaders do not focus on the control or authority they hold. |
Leadership Style | Managers practicing transformational leadership are known for empowering their team members to perform at their highest levels by inspiring motivation and offering intellectual stimulation. | Charismatic leaders emphasize improving the current situation instead of creating a new path. | Unlike the ideas followed under the transformational leadership theory, the leader serves the team to achieve goals. Such leaders may not necessarily inspire teams to upskill or improve. |
Aim | These leaders seek to change people and organizations by fostering a common vision. | Such leaders wish to create an impact on their followers through charisma, charm, and appeal. | Servant leaders aim to lead with humility, cooperation, and selflessness. |