Crowding Out Effect

Last Updated :

Blog Author :

Edited by :

Reviewed by :

Table Of Contents

What Is Crowding Out Effect?

The crowding-out effect explains the reduction in private sector investments induced by increased public sector spending. According to this, when a nation's economy is at full capacity, which leads to rise in government borrowing.

When the government spends more than the usual amount, it can cause a subsequent increase in government borrowings and increase in demand for loans. This rise in the interest rate and a decrease in the number of available funds to satisfy the investment requirements of the private sector. Hence altogether, the government activity crowds out the private investment in the nation.

What Is Crowding Out Effect?

The crowding-out effect of expansionary fiscal policy suggests that when the economy is at its full capacity, an increase in additional spending from the public sector causes a decline in private sector spending.
Government spending is financed through raising taxes or borrowings that involve bonds. Both these ways can reduce the availability of funds for private-sector investment.
The demand for loanable funds rises when the government seeks funds for borrowings. It increases the real interest rate and deters the private sector's investment activities.

Crowding Out Effect Explained

The crowding out effect fiscal policy in macroeconomics is active if the government increases its spending when operating at its full capacity with a significantly lower unemployment rate. It happens because the capital and labor requirements generated in the public sector will naturally reduce the availability of those in the private sector.

However, if the economy is operating below capacity or going through a recession phase with a high unemployment rate and low private spending, the government's initiative to spend more will lighten up the economy by bringing more private investments, employment, and economic growth.

Generally, the government budget deficit can be due to decreased tax revenue and high spending associated with stimulus programs. Common ways through which the government can raise finances are by increasing taxes and borrowing. When the government borrows money, it is generally in bonds, treasury bills, or notes. To make it attractive, the government raises interest rates. An increase in tax liabilities, crowding out effect on investment in the bond,, and real interest rate will leave corporations with less capital to spend. In this instance, private businesses were "crowded out" from investment activities.

Graph

Let us look at the graph of crowding out effect fiscal policy.

The effect is significant whenever the government introduces expansionary fiscal policies. As portrayed in the above graph, the demand curve shifts from D1 to D2 when the need for loanable funds increases due to increased government spending. Before this shift, the equilibrium interest rate and total quantities were I1 and Q1, respectively. After the change, the equilibrium interest rate and total quantity increased to I2 and Q2, respectively. However, it is evident in the graph that with the crowding out effect interest rates rising (I2), the demand curve (D1) encompassing private demand falls back to Q3, which is depicted by point C.

Examples

Here are a few examples of the crowding-out effect, which comes in different types to better understand how economic theory works.

Example #1

A high-profile tech company Orange Inc. is looking to borrow money for investing in its research and development (R&D) to devise new technology capable of enhancing people's lives.

The initial plan was to take out a loan worth $5 million with an interest rate of 4%. However, around the same time, the interest rate started escalating. It increased from 4% to 6%. It happened when the government planned to invest in several developmental projects and collect necessary funds through debt financing. As a result, the demand for loanable funds increased the interest rate and decreased the availability of funds. . Thus, due to crowding out effect interest rates went up which made the company think twice about the investment and its return on it. As a result, the company decides not to invest in the project.

Interest rates go up when the government increases its spending due to the increase in aggregate demand. When there is an increase in aggregate demand, the prices of goods will also increase to compensate for the shift in demand. The above is the actual scenario of the crowding out effect on investment.

Example #2

This scenario depicts a crowding out effect psychology which includes a private construction company called ABC construction, specializing in building alternative energy sources such as wind and solar farms. If the government were to spend on a significant project adjacent to ABC construction, like making an industrial wind farm to power the city, they would be "crowded out" of the sector. As a result, ABC construction would no longer be practical in this area and would, in turn, reduce spending on projects as it would not be profitable to do so.

Crowding Out Effect Vs Crowding In Effect

In crowding out effect psychology, government expenditure negatively affects the private sector, whereas, in crowding in, government expenditure positively affects the private sector. Let us try to understand the differences between them.

Crowding Out Effect	Crowding In Effect
Government spending in public sector leads to fall in private sector demand.	Government spending in public sector leads to rise in private sector demand.
It happens due to rise in tnterest rate and prices.	It is mostly due to infrastructure development.
Useful during economic expansion.	Useful during economic recession.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What is the crowding-out effect of fiscal policy?

The crowding-out effect suggests that the increase in government spending triggers a decrease in private investments in the country. It can be of different types. The most common one occurs when escalation in government borrowing due to expansionary fiscal policies increases the demand for loans and subsequent rise in interest rate curtailing private spending.

What is an example of crowding out?

Consider an example where to balance the increased public spending activities, the government raises taxes. It, in turn, increases the tax liability of people or corporations. So, it will reduce the income earned by the entities, and they rethink the investment plans prepared. Subsequently, the entities will crowd out from spending and investment plans.

What causes a liquidity trap?

The liquidity trap refers to the situation in which clients prefer to hold onto their savings rather than making a bank deposit or further investments. They believe that it would diminish the return during an economic shock or recession.